c-section or vbac, pregnancy, baby, motherhood, cesarean


Csection or VBAC - that is the question. Are you being faced with this decision too? Here, I weigh the pros and cons for both a repeat csection or a vbac as I try to decide what's best for me. #pregnancy #csection #Csectionawareness #delivery #birth #pregnancy #vbac #vbacsuccess

Repeat Csection or VBAC – that is the question…

“Your baby is breech .”

Those are the words I heard during my thirty-two week ultrasound appointment with my first baby. Now, I was pretty familiar with what this meant because I was also a breech baby and knew that my mom had me delivered via cesarean section (C-section) for that reason.

As my doctor further explained, the chances of my baby turning around on her own were very small so we should plan and prepare to have our baby via C-section. She did briefly talk about a method called external cephalic version, or ECV, which is a procedure in which a doctor can try to flip the baby but this was not something that sounded right for me. We set a date for the C-section and that was that. She never ended up turning around so it was out of my tummy she came!

c-section or vbac, pregnancy, birth, baby, parenting

Now, almost three years later, I am more than halfway into my second pregnancy and I am faced with an incredibly hard decision – do I have this baby via C-section or vaginally?

I’ve been doing some research and this seems to be a hot topic. I understand that there are some strong opinions in both directions and I’m definitely not here to say one way is better than the other. I’m writing to share my thoughts and experience with having to make this tough decision because it’s all I seem to think about these days as I get closer to my due date. I would also love to hear from other moms that have had to make this same choice and what your experiences were.

c-section or vbac, cesarean, baby, pregnancy, birth, mom

My doctor has said that I’m a good candidate for VBAC (vaginal birth after C-section) because enough time has passed since my first baby was delivered and I am not high-risk. I am really struggling with this and feel like there is a constant back and forth battle going on in my head these days, trying to ultimately determine the safest method for both me and my baby.

If I knew that a vaginal birth would be an “easy” one with no complications, I would choose that without a question but I have no way of knowing. I understand there are some risks associated with a VBAC and while they are small, they are still something to consider.

I am also faced with my own fears about a delivery method that is completely new to me. What if my baby is large? What if I end up trying to do a VBAC and have to end up doing a C-section anyway? What if I have a long and painful labor? Will I tear and if so, how badly? Will I make it in time for the epidural? These are just a few of the questions that swirl around my head.

My C-section was a bit traumatizing for me. Before the big day, I talked to other women I knew who had also had one and a common phrase I kept hearing was “you will feel some pulling and tugging.” After now experiencing this myself, that is NOT the phrase I would use. It is a feeling I really can’t even describe. To feel someone inside of your body is just incredibly unnatural and was frightening for me.

I am someone who becomes easily faint at the sight of blood and it makes me queasy to think about the inside of our bodies. Therefore, lying on that table and starting to feel the strange feeling of my insides being manipulated was an experience I would much rather never have again. I looked at my husband and said, “I can’t do this!” After that, the rest was a blur until I was in the next room holding my baby.

Don’t get me wrong – there were definitely some positives to having a preplanned C-section. I never experienced a contraction, I could go into the hospital showered and prepared for my stay, there was no rushing and my family could plan around the delivery date.

My recovery went relatively well – or as well as recovery from a major surgery can go. However, I still remember the intense gas pains, the heavy bleeding, the overwhelming fatigue, and more than anything the amount of time it took me to feel like I was back to normal. It was an intense experience that took a toll on me both physically and mentally.

This time around, I will have a toddler to care for and I can’t help but think that whichever way has the quickest recovery time is my best option.

c-section or vbac, pregnancy, baby, birth, cesarean, mom, parenting

Looking back, I didn’t realize how lucky I was to have the decision made for me the first time around. The risks are much higher when trying to deliver a breech baby vaginally so C-section it was and I never thought twice about it.

This time is very different.  The choice is up to me, and I understand that only I can decide what is best for myself and my baby but it is a very tough choice. It’s not like I am deciding what to have for dinner. This decision can have some major consequences for both me and my baby. I am choosing how I want to bring a life into this world and it’s overwhelming. I’m sure I am overthinking this and maybe to some, the answer would be clear. However, that’s not the case for me. Right now, I don’t have the answer to my questions and I may never get them.

I’m not sure what my outcome will be. All I can do these days is pray and trust that whatever I decide will be the right choice.

Have you had a VBAC? Did you have to face this same decision during a pregnancy? I would love to hear your story!

You may also like...


  1. Hi,
    My 1st birth experience was very similar to yours. Breech baby, but I had an emergency C-Section after a failed ECV – they broke my waters accidentally. I chose to have a VBAC at home for my 2nd birth. It was an amazing experience. I was also able to pick up my toddler and reassure him too – which I wouldn’t have been able to do with a C-Section.

    I hope you r 2nd birth went well.

    1. Thank you! Yes, it did go well but ended up being another C-Section. That had to be an amazing experience to do a home birth! So glad it went well for you also. 🙂

  2. What you said in your post is exactly how I feel! My first daughter was breeched and we didn’t get turning her. It didn’t sit well with my husband or I. Here I am almost two and half years later in my third trimester with baby number two and I can’t decide what to do. I am constantly going back and forth between the two options. I love my doctor and the hospital I had my daughter at but I can have a vbac there. I didn’t care for the doctor I saw for the hospital I would deliver at if I tried a vbac. He didnt give me a feeling of confidence in trying a vbac. I’m so lost and overwhelmed.

    1. Hi! I’m so sorry to hear that! I know how hard of a decision that is. I would trust your gut and the doctor played a huge part for me. I was really uncomfortable with one of the doctors that I spoke with about a vbac and in the end, I chose to do another c-section. Do what you think is right for you! Wishing you all the best and a safe delivery. <3

  3. I’m in the exact same position! I had a breech baby for my first pregnancy but the c-section went very smoothly and was a great experience for me because it wasn’t an emergency. I heard quickly and had no major complications. I appreciated that I had to care for an incision and not all the other “ground beef” type situations I heard were associated with a vaginal birth. I felt like I was reading my thoughts typed out when I was reading your post, so thank you for being so honest! I’m still torn but it was nice to read something that didn’t feel like shaming someone for having a repeat c-section. It gave me lots of good questions to ask my doc! Thank you for your honesty!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *